"At the heart of Bad Medievalism are the ghosts of Stuart Hall and J. R. R. Tolkien, whose encounter in 1950s England led to the exclusion of a brilliant Black man from the study of English medieval literature, and created the conditions for his subsequent cofounding of the influential Birmingham school of cultural studies. Lavezzo unpacks this critical encounter with acuity and sensitivity, so that it becomes a node in her larger discourse on periodization, affect and emotion, white medieval studies, and medievalism today. We owe the author a debt for her discovery of how English medieval studies was robbed, and modern cultural studies emerged a winner in the western academy, as well as for her superb analysis of J. R. R. Tolkien. Chapter 3 alone is worth the price of the book." - Geraldine Heng, author of The Invention of Race in the European Middle Ages and The Global Middle Ages: An Introduction
"Do the Middle Ages get you down? Kathryn Lavezzo explains why in her stunning study of medievalisms negative vibes, from its racial complicities and alt-right revivals to the critical pessimism that can fortify medieval studies for our times. Stuart Hall is the hero of this brilliant new account of periodization, the invention of modernity, and the structures of scholarly feeling.<" - Julia Reinhard Lupton, University of California, Irvine
"Kathy Lavezzo's Bad Medievalism is an utterly compelling intervention into medieval studies. The book combines sophisticated critiques of certain idioms of feeling and affect in medievalist scholarship with rigorous inquiries into the politics of periodization and race shaping the field. Rich with insight and brilliantly conceived, the book will inspire discussions about the past, present, and future of medievalism for years to come." - Bruce Holsinger, Linden Kent Memorial Professor of English, University of Virginia
"An interesting and important contribution to the field of Medieval Studies, as well as the intersections of that field with critical theory, including Critical Race Studies. It will appeal to both specialists in the field and a wider public with an interest in the histories of race and racialization." - Suzanne Conklin Akbari, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, NJ
"Touting the 'benefits of kill-joy historicism,' Bad Medievalism is a wide-ranging exploration of race, affect, and the relations between medievalism and the modern, joining broad survey with readings of Gloria Naylor and Paule Marshall's rewritings of medieval materials and brilliantly highlighting a fascinating key encounter, when J. R. Tolkien discouraged his student, Stuart Hall, the future founder of cultural studies, from pursing graduate work in medieval studies. An Impressive achievement." - Jonathan Culler, Cornell University
"Periodization structures how we feel and who we are. Powered by this insight, Lavezzo assembles a remarkable archive of thinkers who together aid in reconceptualizing historical difference and in feeling the medieval/modern boundary anew. Antiracist critique joins creative and speculative practice in this exciting study, to generate new possibilities for medieval studies." - Julie Orlemanski, Department of English, University of Chicago
