"This book challenges the hyper-production and proliferation of concepts in modern social research. It presents a distinctive methodological response to this tendency through an exploration of one of the most underappreciated yet widely deployed conventions for the analysis of social processes: the creation of diagrammatic relational spaces. Designed to capture social process but in a way that resists reductive and essentialist categories, such spaces have the capacity to produce powerful, systematic analyses that break the spell of concept proliferation and its resultant naively realist approach to explaining the world. Through an exploration of key examples and series of original case studies, the authors demonstrate the application of this approach across a variety of empirical settings and academic disciplines. They thus offer a relational and pragmatic approach to social research that resists current trends characterised by supposedly self-evident data and/or disconnected theory. As such, the book constitutes an important contribution to some of the central questions in current social research, and promises to unsettle and reinvigorate considerations of method across different fields of practice"--
This book challenges the hyper-production and proliferation of concepts in modern social research. It presents a distinctive methodological response to this tendency through an exploration of one of the most underappreciated yet widely deployed conventions for the analysis of social processes: the creation of diagrammatic relational spaces. Designed to capture social processes in a way that resists reductive and essentialist categories, such spaces have the capacity to produce powerful, systematic analyses that break the spell of concept proliferation and its resultant naively realist approach to explaining the world. Through an exploration of key examples and series of original case studies, the authors demonstrate the application of this approach across a variety of empirical settings and academic disciplines. They thus offer a relational and pragmatic approach to social research that resists current trends characterised by supposedly self-evident data and/or disconnected theory. As such, the book constitutes an important contribution to some of the central questions in current social research, and promises to unsettle and reinvigorate considerations of method across different fields of practice.
Introduction
1. The sorcerers apprentice syndrome
2. Diagrams as
metaphors of containment
3. At the crossroads: The struggle to escape
categorical diagramming
4. Relational diagramming
5. Ignorance vs. knowledge
in the study of gender and technology
6. Diagramming relational research:
Disentangling relationality from realism Conclusion
Russell Dudley-Smith is lecturer at the UCL Institute of Education, UK. His general research interests are in theoretical sociology and qualitative research methodology. His sociological work has looked at educational settings: the ritualisation of schooling, the formation of elite identities, and the necessary role of negativity in pedagogy. He has a methodological research interest in the varied recontextualisations of philosophy in many branches of social research, including French traditions in the philosophy of science and philosophical pragmatism.
Natasha Whiteman is reader in Media and Communication at the University of Westminster, UK. Her research examines the ethical manoeuvring of media researchers and media consumers, with a particular focus on the study of illicit audience practices. Her methodological interests include the use of observational methods in online research and the formation of ethical subjectivity in qualitative research writing. She is the author of Undoing Ethics: Rethinking Practice in Online Research (2012).
