Atjaunināt sīkdatņu piekrišanu

E-grāmata: Economic Reason and Political Reason - Deliberation and the Construction of Public Space in the Society of Communication [Wiley Online]

(Paris-Panthéon-Assas University, France)
  • Formāts: 368 pages
  • Izdošanas datums: 03-Jan-2023
  • Izdevniecība: ISTE Ltd
  • ISBN-10: 1394188161
  • ISBN-13: 9781394188161
  • Wiley Online
  • Cena: 168,05 €*
  • * this price gives unlimited concurrent access for unlimited time
  • Formāts: 368 pages
  • Izdošanas datums: 03-Jan-2023
  • Izdevniecība: ISTE Ltd
  • ISBN-10: 1394188161
  • ISBN-13: 9781394188161

The public space of democracies is constructed in a context that is marked by the digital transformation of the economy and society. This construction is carried out primarily through deliberation. Deliberation informs and guides both individual and collective action.

To shed light on the concept of deliberation, it is important to consider the rationality of choice; but what type of rationality is this? References to economic reason are at once widespread, crucial and controversial. This book therefore deals with arguments used by individuals based on the notions of preferential choice and rational behavior, and also criticizes them. These arguments are examined in the context of the major themes of public debate that help to construct the contemporary public space: "populism", social insurance, social responsibility and environmental issues.

Economic Reason and Political Reason underlines the importance of the pragmatist shift of the 2000s and revisits, through the lens of this new approach, the great utilitarian and Rawlsian normative constructs that dominated normative political economics at the end of the 20th century. Alternative approaches, based on the concept of deliberative democracy, are proposed and discussed.

Introduction xi
Jean Mercier Ythier
Part 1 Normative Political Economy: Between Economic Reason and Political Reason
1(130)
Chapter 1 The "Difference Principle": Economic Rationality and Political Applicability
3(32)
Claude Gamel
1.1 Introduction: equality norms and the "difference principle" in the public debate
3(7)
1.1.1 Deliberation in public debate
3(2)
1.1.2 The equality standard in evaluating inequalities
5(2)
1.1.3 The singularity of the "difference principle"
7(3)
1.2 Rationality: from philosophical objection to economic translation
10(9)
1.2.1 The philosophical objection rather well overcome
10(3)
1.2.2 An economic translation still under debate
13(6)
1.3 Applicability: from political misunderstanding to societal complexity
19(11)
1.3.1 The political misunderstanding to be cleared up
19(7)
1.3.2 The societal complexity to be absorbed
26(4)
1.4 Conclusion: a principle that is less philosophical than economic
30(1)
1.5 References
31(4)
Chapter 2 The Public Sphere Between the State and the Market: From Rational Discussion to the Information and Communication Society
35(50)
Sylvain Lavelle
2.1 Publicity before and after Habermas
35(3)
2.2 The public sphere between the State and the market
38(10)
2.2.1 The origin of the concept in the public sphere
39(2)
2.2.2 The public sphere and the systems of the State and the market
41(1)
2.2.3 The development of the concept of the public sphere in Between Facts and Norms
42(3)
2.2.4 The multiple dimensions of the public sphere
45(3)
2.3 The public sphere and rational discussion
48(12)
2.3.1 The rational discussion model
48(2)
2.3.2 The political ideal put to the test of reality
50(2)
2.3.3 The critique of reason and discourse
52(4)
2.3.4 The critique of margin and class
56(4)
2.4 The public sphere and the information and communication society
60(8)
2.4.1 The challenges of the information and communication society
60(1)
2.4.2 The public sphere of the media
61(2)
2.4.3 The public sphere in the age of the Internet and globalization
63(3)
2.4.4 The public sphere of the information and communication society
66(2)
2.5 The idea of the political sphere
68(8)
2.5.1 Beyond procedural policy
68(2)
2.5.2 A paradigm shift
70(3)
2.5.3 From the public sphere to the political sphere
73(2)
2.5.4 The political sphere between the State, the market and society
75(1)
2.6 The dialectics of publicity
76(3)
2.7 References
79(6)
Chapter 3 Contracts Rather than Deliberation: Robert Sugden's Normative Economics
85(24)
Bertrand Crettez
3.1 Introduction
85(1)
3.2 Sugden's public reasoning approach
86(2)
3.3 The contractarian point of view: principles
88(4)
3.4 The psychological stability of the market from a contractionary perspective
92(4)
3.5 Discussion of the hypotheses
96(2)
3.6 Making the market more moral
98(4)
3.7 An assessment of the principle of mutual benefit
102(2)
3.8 Conclusion
104(2)
3.9 Acknowledgments
106(1)
3.10 References
107(2)
Chapter 4 From a Hegelian to a Smithian Reading of Rawls
109(22)
Ragip Ege
Herrade Igersheim
4.1 Introduction
109(5)
4.2 Hegel and the reasonable/rational duo
114(9)
4.3 The Smithian impartial spectator: a conceptual trio
123(4)
4.4 Conclusion
127(1)
4.5 References
128(3)
Part 2 Reasons and Persons
131(76)
Chapter 5 Personal Identity, Public Deliberation and Behavioral Public Policy
133(26)
Cyril Hedoin
5.1 Introduction
133(2)
5.2 Behavioral public policy and paternalism
135(4)
5.3 Normative behavioral economics, welfare and identity
139(5)
5.4 Personal identity and the plurality of conceptions of the good
144(4)
5.5 Public deliberation and justification of behavioral public policies
148(6)
5.6 Conclusion
154(1)
5.7 Acknowledgments
155(1)
5.8 References
155(4)
Chapter 6 Preferential Choice, Logical Action and Communication Ethics
159(48)
Jean Mercier Ythier
6.1 Preferential choice and logical action
159(4)
6.2 Practical choice: logical form and phenomenological substance of the preferential choice
163(3)
6.3 Preferential choice and the axioms of rational choice: logical analysis
166(4)
6.4 Deliberate choice as rational preferential choice: logical reconstruction and evaluation
170(26)
6.4.1 Robustness: reflexivity, binarity and acyclicity of the preference relation
172(11)
6.4.2 Accuracy: completeness of the preference relation
183(11)
6.4.3 Transparency: transitivity of the preference relation
194(2)
6.5 A tentative conclusion on epistemology and ethics
196(2)
6.6 Appendix
198(5)
6.7 References
203(4)
Part 3 Public Debate and Public Policy
207(102)
Chapter 7 Issues of "Stakeholder" Recognition in Collaborative Deliberation
209(18)
Emmanuel Picavet
7.1 Introduction
209(1)
7.2 Authority and recognition of contributions
210(8)
7.2.1 Public and private
210(3)
7.2.2 Reciprocal support of actors, recognition and collective initiative
213(3)
7.2.3 Structure of action and structure of its environment
216(2)
7.3 The organization's environment and stakeholders
218(5)
7.3.1 Descriptive choices
218(1)
7.3.2 Contributions of the "stakeholder" approach
219(2)
7.3.3 Endogeneity, exogeneity and power in the commitments of an organization
221(2)
7.4 Conclusion
223(2)
7.5 References
225(2)
Chapter 8 Rethinking the Social Contract in the Digital Age
227(32)
Bruno Deffains
8.1 Introduction
227(5)
8.2 Toward the questioning of the social contract
232(10)
8.2.1 An economic model in question
234(1)
8.2.2 Increasing inequality
235(1)
8.2.3 The end of homo economicus?
236(1)
8.2.4 Attention as a scarce resource
237(1)
8.2.5 The principle of intensity and voluntary servitude
238(4)
8.3 An explosive cocktail!
242(2)
8.4 Re-founding the social contract
244(10)
8.4.1 A look back at "liberating science"
245(3)
8.4.2 Revisiting the human-machine relationship
248(3)
8.4.3 Digital ontology and ethics
251(3)
8.5 Individual responsibility and collective solidarity
254(2)
8.6 Acknowledgments
256(1)
8.7 References
256(3)
Chapter 9 Public Management of Rivers: The Deliberative Test
259(24)
Julie Riegel
9.1 Introduction
259(2)
9.2 Voluntary consultations, between desires and fears of dialog
261(5)
9.2.1 Gaining residents' acceptance of the projects
261(2)
9.2.2 The moderators of the consultations: a regime of sharing rather than opinion
263(3)
9.3 Contrasting memories and effects of the consultation
266(6)
9.3.1 "We were listened to. We were able to talk"
266(3)
9.3.2 A bitter memory of the consultation and unresolved management actions
269(3)
9.4 Framing the consultation and developing scales
272(5)
9.4.1 The status of expertise: determining or supporting the discussion
272(2)
9.4.2 Normativity and scales of general interest in consultations
274(3)
9.5 Conclusion
277(1)
9.6 References
278(5)
Chapter 10 The Economics of Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services between Monetary Valuation and Deliberation
283(26)
Franck-Dominique Vivien
10.1 The economy at the service of nature conservation?
284(8)
10.1.1 Is nature irreplaceable?
284(2)
10.1.2 What is the cost of biodiversity erosion?
286(4)
10.1.3 Continuing the debate on sustainability around ecosystem services
290(2)
10.2 An overview of the controversy surrounding the economic value of nature
292(9)
10.2.1 The standard economic approach and the issue of undervaluing nature in economic terms
292(1)
10.2.2 The London School: environmental pragmatism
293(2)
10.2.3 The conventionalist approach
295(3)
10.2.4 Joan Martinez-Alier's ecological socioeconomics: valuation conflicts and incommensurability
298(1)
10.2.5 A research approach: deliberative monetary evaluation
299(2)
10.3 Conclusion
301(1)
10.4 References
302(7)
List of Authors 309(2)
Index 311
Jean Mercier Ythier is Professor of Economics at the Paris-Panthéon-Assas University, France. His research focuses on political economy, public economics and contemporary economic anthropology.