Preface |
|
v | |
Table of cases |
|
xiii | |
Table of statutes |
|
xxxiii | |
Table of international instruments |
|
xliii | |
Introduction |
|
1 | |
|
1 Relevance and admissibility of evidence |
|
|
17 | |
|
The respective functions of judge and jury |
|
|
19 | |
|
|
22 | |
|
The so-called 'best evidence principle' |
|
|
26 | |
|
Matters of which proof is unnecessary |
|
|
28 | |
|
Judicial findings as evidence |
|
|
34 | |
|
Prejudicial evidence, unfairly obtained evidence and suspect witnesses |
|
|
44 | |
|
Evidence excluded as a matter of public policy |
|
|
59 | |
|
|
66 | |
|
|
67 | |
|
2 Presumptions and the burden of proof |
|
|
69 | |
|
The 'legal burden of proof' and the 'evidential burden' |
|
|
70 | |
|
|
72 | |
|
The prosecution's legal burden of proof in criminal cases |
|
|
74 | |
|
When the defendant in a criminal case bears the legal burden of proof |
|
|
76 | |
|
|
82 | |
|
|
84 | |
|
The judge's 'invisible burden' |
|
|
86 | |
|
The burden of proof when establishing admissibility of evidence |
|
|
89 | |
|
Presumptions and the incidence of the burden of proof |
|
|
90 | |
|
Reversal of the burden of proof and the European Convention on Human Rights |
|
|
91 | |
|
|
117 | |
|
|
118 | |
|
3 Witnesses: competence, compellability and various privileges |
|
|
119 | |
|
The competence of witnesses in civil and criminal cases |
|
|
120 | |
|
The compellability of witnesses |
|
|
122 | |
|
Sworn and unsworn evidence |
|
|
130 | |
|
Privileges enjoyed by certain classes of witness |
|
|
131 | |
|
|
147 | |
|
|
151 | |
|
|
152 | |
|
4 The course of the trial |
|
|
155 | |
|
|
156 | |
|
|
157 | |
|
The judge's right to call a witness |
|
|
158 | |
|
|
159 | |
|
|
160 | |
|
|
164 | |
|
|
183 | |
|
Calling evidence relating to witnesses' veracity |
|
|
184 | |
|
The Crown's right to reopen its case |
|
|
190 | |
|
Special protections extended to various classes of witness in criminal cases |
|
|
192 | |
|
|
219 | |
|
|
219 | |
|
5 Witnesses' previous consistent statements and the remnants of the rule against narrative |
|
|
221 | |
|
The rule excluding previous consistent statements |
|
|
222 | |
|
Evidence-in-chief delivered by video recording (Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 137) |
|
|
243 | |
|
Statements made by the accused when first taxed with incriminating facts |
|
|
244 | |
|
Statements made by the accused when incriminating articles are recovered |
|
|
246 | |
|
|
246 | |
|
|
247 | |
|
6 Character and credibility |
|
|
249 | |
|
|
249 | |
|
The concept of 'credibility' |
|
|
251 | |
|
Bringing out the character of the parties and their witnesses |
|
|
252 | |
|
Evidence of the defendant's good character |
|
|
257 | |
|
|
265 | |
|
|
266 | |
|
7 Evidence of the defendant's bad character |
|
|
267 | |
|
Whether or not to admit evidence of a defendant's misconduct on other occasions |
|
|
269 | |
|
I. The admission of evidence of a defendant's bad character in criminal cases: Part 11 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 |
|
|
273 | |
|
II. Similar fact evidence in civil cases |
|
|
341 | |
|
|
344 | |
|
|
345 | |
|
8 The opinion rule and the presentation of expert evidence |
|
|
347 | |
|
The general rule excluding evidence of opinion |
|
|
348 | |
|
Four exceptions to the opinion rule born of necessity |
|
|
349 | |
|
The principal exception to the opinion rule: expert opinion |
|
|
350 | |
|
Scientific evidence: the presentation of DNA evidence |
|
|
371 | |
|
Scientific evidence: the presentation of Bayes theorem and instructing the jury in mathematical probabilities |
|
|
375 | |
|
|
377 | |
|
|
378 | |
|
9 The rule against hearsay |
|
|
379 | |
|
The rationale underlying a rule against hearsay |
|
|
380 | |
|
I. Hearsay in criminal cases |
|
|
383 | |
|
II. Hearsay in civil proceedings |
|
|
445 | |
|
|
449 | |
|
|
449 | |
10 Confessions |
|
453 | |
|
What constitutes a 'confession' under PACE, s 82(1)? |
|
|
456 | |
|
At common law an accused's silence may amount to an admission |
|
|
457 | |
|
Can a denial ever amount to a 'confession' under PACE, s 82(1)? |
|
|
459 | |
|
The conditions for admissibility of confessions under PACE |
|
|
463 | |
|
What if the accused, having first made an inadmissible confession, later makes a further confession which is obtained by proper methods? |
|
|
478 | |
|
Confessions made by mentally handicapped persons (PACE, s 77) |
|
|
479 | |
|
The admissibility of evidence discovered in consequence of an inadmissible confession |
|
|
480 | |
|
The status of 'mixed statements' |
|
|
481 | |
|
An accused's statement to the police is not normally evidence against other co-accused |
|
|
482 | |
|
An accused's right to use his co-accused's confession (Criminal Justice Act 2003 s 128) |
|
|
486 | |
|
|
491 | |
|
|
492 | |
11 Drawing adverse inferences from a defendant's omissions, lies or false alibis |
|
495 | |
|
I. Inferences drawn from the defendant's silence: the Criminal Justice and Public and Order Act 1994 |
|
|
496 | |
|
II. The silence provisions of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 |
|
|
501 | |
|
III. Inferences drawn from lies told by the defendant: Lucas directions |
|
|
541 | |
|
IV. Inferences drawn from false alibis put forward by the defendant |
|
|
545 | |
|
|
546 | |
|
|
546 | |
12 Identification evidence |
|
549 | |
|
The inherent unreliability of evidence of identification |
|
|
550 | |
|
The Court of Appeal's decision in Turnbull |
|
|
550 | |
|
Identification procedures and PACE, Code D |
|
|
560 | |
|
Code D and the various methods of identification |
|
|
567 | |
|
|
577 | |
|
|
577 | |
13 Documents |
|
579 | |
|
|
580 | |
|
Proof of 'public documents' and 'judicial documents' |
|
|
580 | |
|
Proof of 'private documents' by primary evidence |
|
|
581 | |
|
Proof of 'private documents' by means of copies |
|
|
582 | |
|
Proof of 'private documents' by means of other forms of secondary evidence |
|
|
583 | |
|
|
585 | |
|
|
587 | |
Index |
|
589 | |