This book examines 100 years of media coverage, decades of medical debate, and overlapping sport regulatory policies, this book considers how the force of cisgender ideology creates a singular narrative centered on fairness that dominates transgender and intersex women and erases them from elite sport.
Sex and gender are interconnected, conflated, different, and complex. Arguably, there is no cultural arena more affected by the complexity of sex/gender than sport, where the presumed need for a male/female binary is personalized, medicalized, and politicized. Gender Defenders of the Sport Binary considers how medical, policy, and media discourses shape understanding of nonbinary athletes, and more broadly cultural understandings of gender as chosen and sex as biologically measurable.
Tracing discourse across more than 100 years of media coverage, decades of medical debate, and overlapping sport regulatory policies, this book considers how the force of cisgender ideology creates a singular narrative centered on fairness that dominates transgender and intersex women and erases them from elite sport. This book traces the influence of powerful contexts such as language and masculinity in constructing boundaries around who can and cannot fit in womens sport.
"In Gender Defenders of the Sport Binary, Bell and Osborne offer a compelling and incisive critique of how sport, medicine, and the media converge to police gender under the guise of fairness. In a time of global debates on gender and athleticism, this thought-provoking book unpacks the exclusionary frameworks that elite sport uses to marginalize transgender and intersex athletes, revealing the deep entanglements between gender ideology and power. Using meticulous research and sharp analysis, the authors challenge us to reconsider the boundaries of inclusion, presenting a vital call to reimagine sport as a space where diversity is not disciplined, but celebrated."
Anna Baeth, Ph.D., Director of Research, Athlete Ally
Introduction: Sex as Fundamental to Womens Sport Discourse of
Defense: Sport Policy as a Foundation of Sex- Segregation Discourse of
Diagnosis: Medicalizing Intersex and Transgender Discourse of Difference:
American Newspaper Coverage from 19001959 Discourse of Dissuasion: Sports
Institutionalization of Testing Femininity, 19601969 Discourse of
Defiance: Athletes Finally Have a Voice, 19701999 Discourse of Division:
Sex Segregation Under the Cloak of Gender Inclusion, 20002016 Discourse of
Cis- Duty: A Panicked Return to Sex Exclusion, 20172023 Conclusion:
Discourse of Destruction: Emphasized Femininity to Discipline Gender for
Intersex and Transgender Athletes Index.
Travis R. Bell is an Associate Professor at the University of South Florida. He teaches visual storytelling, sports media, and media theory. His research spans communication and sport, publishing in Communication & Sport, International Journal of Sport Communication, and Sociology of Sport. He is lead author of CTE, Media, and the NFL (2019).
Anne C. Osborne is Professor of Communications at the S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University. She teaches and conducts research at the intersections of gender, sport, and media. She has published peer-reviewed articles in International Journal of Sport Communication, Journal of Public Relations Research, and Sport in Society, and she is lead author of Female Fans of the NFL: Taking their Place in the Stands (2016).
