It Might Have Been is a romantic novel about the effects of an arranged marriage. Beginning in the Ukraine at the start of the last century, two teenagers Rita and Daniel are in love. Daniel has no money, so her father marries her off to a wealthy merchant Mikal. All migrate to America where Mikal opens a successful lighting store whereas Daniel becomes a doctor. Rita and Daniel run into each other, and
still in love
they begin an affair. She already has a son, Nathan. Rita and Daniel consider the boys age, and they know that Nathan is actually Daniels son. Mikal finds out about the affair, but they all know that the boy should never know who his real father is. Meanwhile Mikals store loses money. Mikal is then older and tries to move a heavy crate by himself. The crate falls and traps him underneath. Nathan is there. Daniel has enough strength to tell the teenage Nathan to get the doctor. As Mikal dies, he tells Daniel Be good to them. Eventually, Daniel does marry Rita, but the truth of Nathans parentage is something they keep secret for the rest of their lives.