What is at stake in Freuds enduring preoccupation with a process supposedly diverting sexuality into cultural activity? In this study, a leading scholar of psychoanalysis and literature re-opens the old question of sublimation in a critical reading that explores one of the last remaining puzzles of Freudian thought. Using the rigorous framework provided by Jean Laplanche, Luke Thurston resituates sublimation as an unfinished Freudian concept bound up with a much wider history of philosophical and literary reflection. Exploring the misunderstanding and reinvention of sublimation both in accounts of cultural history and in Lacans celebrated reading of Antigone, Thurston challenges some of the prevalent assumptions still seen in contemporary Theory. Thurston links his critical investigation of psychoanalysis to modernist literature, discovering both parallels and alternatives to Freuds idea of sublimation in little-known works by May Sinclair and David Jones. The study concludes by arguing that these modernist artists, both of whom were significantly affected by trauma during the First World War, produced work radically at odds with the established canons of representation, and that this anti-hermeneutic art can be linked to a Copernican sublimation, a process not controlled by the ego but vitalizing it and decentring its habitual structure.
Understanding Sublimation in Freudian Theory and Modernist Writing resituates sublimation as an unfinished Freudian concept bound up with a much wider history of philosophical and literary reflection.
Introduction SublimationThe Unfinished Theory
Part 1 Metaphor and Metapsyche
Theoretical Prologue: Translating Sublimation
Chapter 1 Freud: the Cleavage of Sense and Horror
Chapter 2 Sublimation and the Ethical
Chapter 3 Sublimation and Anti-Hermeneutics
Interlude Sublimation, War and Modernism
Part 2 Modernism: Drives and Defences
Chapter 4 May Sinclair at the Front
Chapter 5 Halsing David Jones
Conclusion Primal Sublimation
Luke Thurston is Director of the David Jones Centre at Aberystwyth University. He is the author of James Joyce and the Problem of Psychoanalysis (2004) and Literary Ghosts from the Victorians to Modernism (2012), the co-editor (with Scott Brewster) of The Routledge Handbook to the Ghost Story (2018) and the translator of Jean Laplanches The Unfinished Copernican Revolution (2020).